When the Kenyan government announced five years ago that coal deposits had been found in the Mui Basin, a land of rolling hills and pristine forests east of Nairobi, local farmers hoped the discovery would help transform their livelihoods.
But as villagers prepare to leave their loamy, fertile soils to make way for the multi-million dollar mine and power station development, many households fear they will miss out on compensation because women do not have titles to their land.
Traditionally, Kenyan society is patriarchal and ownership and decisions on land management or disposal are made by men.
The villagers’ situation reflects the predicament of thousands of women throughout Kenya who head their households but are not named on land ownership documents.
Around 30,000 households will be affected by the proposed coal mines in the Mui basin, said Alex Nganga, leader in the local county assembly.
There are no definitive figures for how many local families are headed by women, but it is known that there are many.
“We were anticipating that women would be listed in title deeds as co-owners or joint owners of land,” said Kasyoka Malonza, a Mutito community representative in the Mui Basin.
“It’s unfortunate that we have not been recognized despite all our efforts,” she said.
A NATIONAL PROBLEM
According to the Federation of Women Lawyers (FIDA), Kenya now has a raft of progressive laws aimed at ensuring gender equality but customary laws continue to limit women’s rights to land and property.
The Land Registration Act, introduced in 2012, includes provisions for joint tenancy and gives wives a legal right to land that is held in the other spouse’s name where the woman has contributed either in financial terms or through her labor.
FIDA estimates that only five percent of all land title deeds are held jointly by women with men and only one percent of land titles in Kenya are held by women alone.
This is despite figures that show that around 32 per cent of households are headed by women and that they are responsible for nearly 90 per cent of the farming work.
A report on gender issues and the effect of coal mining in the Mui Basin prepared last year with Canadian government support also highlighted the need to ensure fair compensation for land women who live in polygamous households.
MORE POWER FOR KENYA
The coal-rich Mui Basin covers around 500 square km and is located around 270 km (170 miles) east of Nairobi. It has been divided into four sections for mining development.
A Chinese firm, Fenxi Mining Group, was given rights to develop half the area in 2011. Another Chinese company, HCIG Energy Investment Company with Liketh Investments Kenya Ltd won rights to develop the rest of the area and coal fired plant in 2015.
The east African nation hopes that coal from the $2 billion power plant will not only help supply Kenya’s cement and steel industries which import large volumes of coal but also save on foreign exchange by cutting import costs. Surplus electricity will be sold into Kenya’s national grid.
George Kariithi, director of the Great Lakes Corporation, a Kenyan partner of the Fenxi Mining Group said the company could not comment on the issue of land compensation and ownership rights.
“We have left that for the government to handle,” he told the Thomson Reuters Foundation.
A spokesman for the National Land Commission told the Thomson Reuters Foundation that questions on land titles and the mining development must be referred to the Kitui County government.
But an official for the county said he could not comment as it was a matter for the Land Commission.
WOMEN FIGHT BACK
Christine Kalikanda of the advocacy group Centre for Human Rights and Civic Education (CHRCE) said the group was working in the Mui Basin as well as many other areas of Kenya to teach women how to ask for their property rights.
“We mobilise communities to voice issues collectively,” she said, adding that CHRCE has also developed guidelines to help villagers negotiate fair, market value compensation.
According to local residents however, there has been very little interaction between the mining companies and local communities.
Activists say that the government itself has not been forthcoming either and communities still have no idea where churches, markets and water points are to be re-located.
Simon Mutui of the campaign group Kenya NGO Council said widows and single parents are particularly worried as they have no legal claim to their land at all.
“Children born out of wedlock stay with their maternal extended families but have no claim to land as their mothers lack inheritance rights, they have no claim to compensation,” he said.
For Mutito community representative, Malonza, the answer lies with the Kenyan government: “It should guarantee women’s rights both for ownership and the equitable division of assets,” she said.
“We want to see that even women in polygamous families get an equal share.”
(Reporting by Shadrack Kavilu and Justus Wanzala, Editing by Paola Totaro, Thomson Reuters Foundation.